On 20 October 2026 we counted every Google listing for five trades within 15–20 km of central London, Manchester and Birmingham: 18,495 listings (method). We recorded the map 3-pack for each trade and city. Then we asked ChatGPT and Perplexity "Who are the best {trade} in {city}?" for the same 15 searches, plus a ChatGPT re-run of the plumber question in each city: 33 answers in all (method).
| UK trade listings | Share | n |
|---|
| Claimed by the business | 76.3% | 18,495 |
| With a website on the profile | 61.3% | 18,495 |
| With no reviews at all | 27.7% | 18,495 |
| With 10 or more reviews | 33.8% | 18,495 |
| With 100 or more reviews | 4.6% | 18,495 |
| 3-pack entries with 100 or more reviews | 55.6% | 45 |
| AI picks with 100 or more reviews | 59.0% | 166 |
Source: Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026, UK edition, 20 October 2026 (method).
The median 3-pack business had 108 Google reviews; in London it was 133, in Manchester 101 and in Birmingham 95 (method). Every 3-pack entry had at least 10. Review volume is not the only factor, but a profile with a dozen reviews rarely competes with one that has a hundred, and the gap only closes if reviews keep coming in every month.
The pattern holds outside the trades. In London on 28 October 2026, between 17.3% of car dealers' and 69.4% of vets' listings had 100 or more Google reviews, across nine consumer industries from restaurants to dentists, and across four cities 90.0% of the AI picks with a known review count had 100 or more (method).