Skip to content

Method

Published 9 November 2026

How we count win rate

Every number in an Alfred report should be one you can recount by hand. These are the rules: which searches are tracked, which competitors count, on which surfaces, and when a search is won.

42% Won

Worked example
  • Won 27
  • Tracked searches 65
  • Google Maps, grid 21 / 49

  • Google Search 4 / 6

  • AI answers 2 / 10

How is Alfred's win rate calculated?

Win rate is the share of tracked searches where a location comes out ahead of the competitors customers see next to it, on Google Search, Maps and AI answers. Searches and competitors are chosen with you, per location, and every part of the calculation is shown. A search is won by being ahead of all of them. The surfaces rarely agree: in October 2026, 21.9% of ChatGPT's picks were in Google's map top three (method).

  • 21.9% of ChatGPT's local picks were also in Google's map top three for the same search Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026: 57 of 260 picks, five trades in ten cities in Sweden, the UK and the US, 20 October 2026
  • 11.6% of Perplexity's local picks were in the map top three Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026: 45 of 388 picks, 20 October 2026
  • 30 of 53 of ChatGPT's picks in ten cities were still in its answer when the same question was asked again Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026: one re-run per city in 10 cities, 20 October 2026
  • 13 of 15 UK trade searches had the directory Checkatrade in Google's top ten results (Yelp: 13 of 15 in the US) Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026: 15 searches per market, 20 October 2026

What counts: one search, one surface, one location

A tracked search is a search term, a place to search from and a surface to search on. “Plumber Manchester” searched on Google Maps from Manchester city centre is one search. The same term searched from Salford is another. The same question put to ChatGPT is a third.

Searches are chosen with you, per location. They start from the terms customers use for what you sell where you are. Your Google Business Profile’s primary category gives the first term: “dentist” for a practice in Chicago, “AC repair” for a firm in Dubai. The list is printed in the report and changes only when you and we agree, so the number can be compared from one month to the next.

Competitors are the businesses customers see next to you in those searches. They are chosen with you too, per location, and named in the report.

Directories and platforms never count as competitors, although they fill the results. In October 2026, Checkatrade ranked in Google’s organic top ten in 13 of 15 UK trade searches, and Yelp in 13 of 15 US trade searches (method). In the UAE, AI answers named booking platforms as if they were local firms. In Sharjah’s handyman answers, both assistants put one first and named no local business at all (method). A directory page above you is not a firm that took the job. It is taken out, so win rate is only about the businesses competing for the same customer.

The three surfaces

Each search is tracked on the surface where it happens, and all three go into the same share.

Surface What is read What counts as ahead
Google Maps The map results for the term, searched from a fixed point Your location is higher in the list than every chosen competitor
Google Search The organic results for the term, searched from the town or city Your location’s page or profile ranks above the competitors’; directory pages are removed first
AI answers The answer to a question such as “Which plumber in Leeds would you recommend?” Your location is named, and named before the chosen competitors; if no competitor is named, being named is enough

The map is read from several points, because the result depends on where the searcher stands. Google ranks local results on relevance, distance and prominence (Google Business Profile Help). In the free check that means 49 points in a 7 × 7 grid around the business. In ongoing tracking it is the grid agreed for the location’s area. Each point is a search of its own in the share.

AI answers are read by putting the same question to each assistant, once per measurement. Google uses no special markup to choose what appears in its AI features; the same content and structure that decide search results decide there too (Google Search Central).

When a search is won

A search is won when your location is ahead of every chosen competitor in that result. If one competitor is ahead, the search is lost. If your location does not appear, it is lost. Ties do not happen on the map or in search results. When an AI answer names you and a competitor in one sentence, the order in the text decides.

A location’s win rate is the number of searches won divided by the number tracked, over the measurement period. Each surface weighs as much as the number of searches it contributes. A location with 49 map points, 6 organic searches and 10 AI questions has 65 tracked searches, so the map weighs most.

For a group, win rate is counted the same way: every location’s won searches divided by every location’s tracked searches. The location with the most searches weighs most, so the report always prints the group’s share next to each location’s, and a large location never hides a small one.

Worked example

A worked example with made-up numbers: one location over one month, so you can redo the sum by hand. Each row is a surface, and won divided by tracked gives the share.

Surface Tracked searches Won
Google Maps, grid 49 21
Google Search 6 4
AI answers 10 2
Total 65 27

With these made-up numbers, 27 won out of 65 tracked gives a win rate of 42%. On the map alone the share is 43%, in search results 67% and in AI answers 20%. The last row is the one that says what to work on next.

The free check: a win rate from the map

Check my business counts a simpler version, so that it runs in about a minute without you choosing searches first. It compares your business with its full potential, never with another business: each line shows its gap to a fixed target.

  • The search is one term: what people in your market type for your business’s primary Google category, in your market’s spelling, for example “plumber”. You see the term and can change it.
  • The points are 49, in a 7 × 7 grid around the business’s address. In the free check, win rate is the share of map points where you are in the top 3, not a comparison with a competitor. An example with made-up numbers: 9 of 49 points gives 18%, and 40 points are left.
  • Points that could not be checked never count as a gap.
  • Nothing is kept about other businesses.

The thresholds are fixed and never tuned per business:

Line Target Green, Good Amber, Could be better Red, Needs fixing
Local search Top 3 at every point 37–49 of 49 25–36 0–24
Reviews: count and rating Shown, no colour – – –
Reviews without a reply, of the latest read All answered 0 1–3 4 or more
Website: load time on a phone 2.5 seconds or less 2.5 s or less 4 s or less More than 4 s
Website: pages per service, per area and a way to book All that apply All Some None

Source: the check’s fixed thresholds, set by Alfred and published here (Check my business, November 2026). The load-time limits are Google’s (web.dev).

With fewer than 40 points answered the map gets no colour. The load time uses Google’s line for a good load on a phone: the largest content appears within 2.5 seconds (web.dev).

The check is a sample of one term at one moment. A line that could not be checked says so instead of showing a zero.

How often it is updated, and how it stays comparable

Three things are held fixed between measurements: the search terms, the points and the competitors. If you change one of them, the change and its date are printed in the report, and the share before and after the change is not compared like for like. The monthly report per group and location shows win rate next to map rankings and AI visibility, rating and replies, and data accuracy. It also carries the calls, website clicks and direction requests Google reports.

Every single result is stored with the raw answer from its source: the list on the map, the results page, the text of the AI answer. That is how a number in a report can be traced back to the request that produced it.

Why a share and not a ranking

A ranking describes one surface, one search and one moment. Customers move across three surfaces, and the surfaces rarely agree. In October 2026 the AI assistants’ recommendations were compared with Google’s map for the same trade search, in 50 trade and city cells in Sweden, the UK and the US. 21.9% of ChatGPT’s picks and 11.6% of Perplexity’s were in the map top three (method). Of the 150 top-three places on the map, 73 went to a business that either assistant named (method).

The assistants disagree with each other as well. Perplexity named 11.4% of the businesses ChatGPT picked in the UK, against 60.8% in the US (method). The answers move too. Asked the plumber question a second time, ChatGPT kept 30 of its 53 first picks across ten cities, and 44.4% of them in the UK (method). A business can top the map on Tuesday and be missing from the AI answer on Wednesday. A share of many tracked searches, measured again and again against the same competitors, tells you if you are winning. A ranking cannot.

Limits

  • Google personalises results. What you see on your own phone can differ from what is measured, because Google weighs search history, device and exact position. That is why point, term and time are always stated.
  • The map is one surface of several. Google Maps, the local pack in search results and the expanded map list can give different orders. Map results are read per coordinate, and the report says which.
  • AI answers vary between runs. An AI answer is a sample until it has been repeated many times. AI questions sit in the share with their own count, and we say how many answers lie behind it.
  • Rank data can be blocked. Google limits automated searches. A measurement that did not go through is shown as a gap and never filled with a guess.
  • Small samples move a lot. A location with few tracked searches gets a win rate that jumps when one search changes hands. The report says how many searches sit behind every share.

Check the number yourself

  1. Ask for the list. Terms, points and competitors per location are in the report, and in a demo we go through it with you: United Kingdom, United States, United Arab Emirates.
  2. Redo a search. Open Google Maps in a private window, search for the term from one of the points and compare the order with the reading taken at the same time.
  3. Ask the AI question yourself, in the same words, and see who is named. Expect the answer to differ a little from the reading: AI answers vary between runs, which is why they are measured many times.
  4. Recount the share with the table above: won divided by tracked, surface by surface and in total.

See where there is more to win.

Type your business name and get a free check in about a minute.

No credit card · No meeting needed