Win rate per location: who wins, who needs a boost
An average across your sites hides the ones that are losing. Win rate per location shows which win on their own, which are behind, why, and what to do next.
- 1 Purley Heating Co ★ 4.7 · 210 reviews · 1.3 mi
- 2 Dalesway Heating Croydon ★ 4.6 · 58 reviews · 0.3 mi You
- 3 Selhurst Boilers ★ 4.4 · 132 reviews · 1.1 mi
A ranking shows one surface, one search, one moment. A share shows whether the site is winning.
From our study
17 of 79 ChatGPT picks in the UK that also held a 3-pack place for the same search
That is why win rate counts three surfaces, not one. Asked for the best local businesses in 15 searches in London, Manchester and Birmingham, ChatGPT named 79 businesses and only 17 of them were in Google's 3-pack for the same search; for Perplexity it was 12 of 107 (method). A site measured on the map alone can look strong and still be missing when a customer asks an assistant. Answers move as well: re-asked, ChatGPT kept 44.4% of its first-run picks (method), so the figure is measured again every month.
Source: Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026, UK edition, 15 searches and 33 answers, 20 October 2026 (method)
The map part of the figure.
On the map, each point across the site's area is a search of its own. Alfred records where the site ranks at every point and whether it comes out ahead of the rivals you chose.
How it is counted
Four parts, chosen with you, per location
-
The searches
The terms customers use to find what that site does in its own area, such as boiler repair Croydon, emergency dentist near me or hair salon Clapham. Each site gets its own list.
-
The competitors
The businesses customers see next to that site on the map, in search results and in AI answers. Not everyone in the industry, and never your other sites. Directory pages are taken out.
-
The surfaces
Each tracked search is read on Google Search, Google Maps or in an AI answer. The map is read from many points across the site's area, because the result depends on where the searcher stands.
-
The share
Searches won divided by searches tracked. A search is won when the site is ahead of every chosen competitor in that result. The group's figure is every site's wins over every site's searches; the full method is on How we count.
Furthest behind first
A next step for each status
Every site sits in one of four bands next to its own competitors. The band says what kind of problem it has, and the next action says what to do about it this week: fix a listing, answer reviews, add photos or move ad budget.
- Far behind: few reviews or a profile nobody owns. Start with the basics and ask every customer.
- Behind: ranks well without ads, but rivals' ads sit above it. Move ad budget here.
- Ahead: one rival still wins more often on reviews. Answer them and keep asking.
- Well ahead: wins without ads. Lower the ad spend here.
One site, one month: reading the figure
A made-up month for one invented site in Croydon.
| Surface (made-up figures) | Searches tracked | Won | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Maps, grid points | 49 | 20 | 41% |
| Google Search | 8 | 5 | 63% |
| AI answers | 6 | 1 | 17% |
| This site | 63 | 26 | 41% |
In the example (made-up figures), the site's 41% says it is behind its local competitors in most searches, but the rows say why. Its own website does well in search results. The map is held back by reviews: 58 against a rival's 210. And the AI answers rarely name it. The first thing to check there is whether the profile, the website and the directory listings tell one consistent story about the business.
So the next actions are two, not one: ask every customer for a review, and make the trading name, area and services identical on every listing. Neither needs more ad budget.
The reason beside the number
Reviews, ads above you, or a listing error
A low win rate has a cause, and the cause is printed next to it. Each cause has its own fix.
- Reviews The rival ahead most often has more reviews or a better rating. Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking.
- Ads above you The site ranks well, but rivals' ads are shown higher. In Google Ads, the position above rate shows how often another advertiser's ad was shown above yours.
- Listing errors Wrong hours, an old phone number, a duplicate profile or a name that differs between maps. Fixed once, checked every week.
Ad budget by status
The budget follows the win rate
Sites that win without ads need less budget. Sites losing to paid rivals need more. Alfred suggests the month's split matched to where each location is behind, next to an even split, and targets and budget are agreed with you up front.
- An even split and a split by status, side by side
- Each move explained by the searches where rivals' ads sit above you
- Sites that win without ads get a suggestion to spend less
Every site, every week
The work behind the figure
Win rate is reported monthly. The work behind it shows every week, per location.
- 41%
- Win rate, this site
- ALFRED
- 63
- Tracked searches
- ALFRED
- 58
- Google reviews
- GOOGLE PROFILE
What the report holds
- Map position at every grid point, for the searches you chose
- Whether the site is named when customers ask AI who to call
- The rival ahead and what changed there: reviews, photos, ads
- The next action and who at the site owns it
- Which changes went live on maps and directories
Average position or win rate?
Most reports for chains show an average position per site. It is easy to count and hard to act on.
| Average position | Win rate per location | |
|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Where the site lands on average, usually on Google alone | How often the site comes out ahead of its own competitors, on three surfaces |
| What it hides | Third everywhere can mean two rivals always ahead | Nothing about why, unless the reason sits beside it, which it does here |
| Who it compares you with | Nobody in particular | The businesses customers see next to that site |
| What it says about budget | Nothing | Where ads are needed and where they can come down |
| How you read it | One number that should go up | A list, furthest behind first |
The bar differs from town to town as well, because every site faces different competitors. The same average position can mean a comfortable lead in one town and a losing streak in the next. Win rate measures each site against its own competitors.
What is win rate and how do multi-location brands use it?
Win rate is the share of tracked searches where a location comes out ahead of the competitors customers see next to it, on Google Search, Maps and AI answers. A brand with many sites counts it per location and adds it up for the group. The list is sorted furthest behind first, with the reason and the next action beside each site, so the week starts where it matters most.
Sources3
Published 9 November 2026 · Last updated 9 November 2026
Part of Multi-location
What moves the figure
Questions
Straight answers.
How do you rank number one in SEO?
For a local search there is no single first place: the map result changes from street to street, and AI answers name different businesses from Google's. A more useful aim is to come out ahead of the competitors next to you in as many searches as possible, which is what win rate counts. Google says there is no way to pay for a better local ranking (Google).
Is SEO still relevant in 2026?
Yes, and it now covers more ground: the map pack, the organic results and the AI answers that assistants build from profiles, websites and directories. For a business with several sites, the question is which sites it is working for. Win rate per location answers that, site by site.
Benchmark your locations
See which of your sites are behind.
Book a demo and Alfred benchmarks them all: each site's win rate, the competitors ahead of it and where the budget does most good first.
Book a demoFree · No credit card