Skip to content
A smiling barista in a mustard beanie holds a portafilter in a coffee shop
Reputation management · United States

Reputation management: the best reviews win

Alfred asks your customers for reviews after every job or visit, answers positive ones in your voice and routes critical ones to a person with a calm draft, at every location, inside the FTC's rules.

Searched on Google Maps “ac repair near me” · Montrose, Houston Example
  1. 1 Westheimer Cooling Co. ★ 4.7 · 541 reviews · 1.6 mi
  2. 2 Lindale Air & Heat ★ 4.9 · 318 reviews · 0.8 mi You
  3. 3 Heights Comfort Pros ★ 4.6 · 203 reviews · 2.3 mi

The shortlist goes to the businesses with the reviews. The job goes to the one whose replies people trust.

8 of 35 times the review count ChatGPT showed for a US business matched its Google profile

From our study

Reputation travels beyond Google. When ChatGPT named a US business and printed its review count, the figure matched the Google profile in only 8 of 35 checks (method); the gaps traced back to Yelp data and to review cards attached to the wrong listing. Meanwhile only 9.7% of 2,704 Chicago trade listings had 100 or more Google reviews (method). A thin or stale Yelp page can be the rating a customer sees, even though Yelp asks you not to request reviews there.

Source: Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026, US edition, 35 checks and 2,704 Chicago listings, October 20, 2026 (method)

Win rate

Reviews move you up the map, block by block.

Google weighs reviews in its local ranking alongside relevance and distance. Alfred tracks where each location makes the top three across its service area, so you see what a month of answered reviews does to your position.

Westheimer Cooling Co. 66%
Lindale Air & Heat 59%
Heights Comfort Pros 51%
River Oaks Climate 37%
See your own win rate, free
Example
D. ★★ ★★★ · Yesterday

Tech showed up on time but the quote doubled once he was in the attic. Felt like a bait and switch.

Reply from Lindale Air & Heat

Thanks for telling us, and we're sorry the price came as a surprise. That's not how a quote should work with us. Please call our service manager at the number on your invoice so we can go through it with you.

Draft routed to the service manager. A person approves it before it posts.

Ask, reply, approve

Every review answered. Every critical one seen by a person.

Alfred asks your customers for reviews after every job or visit. Star-only reviews get an automatic thank-you. Positive reviews with text get a reply in your voice, posted right away or held for approval, set per location. A critical review gets a calm draft that owns the problem and offers a direct line, and it goes to the right manager, who approves it before it posts.

  • One request flow for every customer, with nothing offered in return
  • Replies that sound like your business, not a template
  • Critical replies always approved by a person
  • Approval rules you set location by location

How it works

The review routine at every location

The same four steps run whether you have one location or a hundred.

  1. Request

    After every job or visit the customer gets a request with your Google review link. Everyone gets it, and nobody is offered cash, a gift or a sweepstakes entry for writing one.

  2. Reply

    Star-only reviews are thanked automatically. Positive reviews with text get a reply in your voice, posted directly or after approval.

  3. Route

    Critical reviews go to the right person, at head office or the location, with a calm draft. A person approves the reply before it posts.

  4. Report

    Rating and replies per location, next to the businesses customers compare you with, and anything still waiting for a person.

US rules

The FTC review rule and the platform policies, in plain English

Since October 21, 2024, a breach of the FTC rule lets courts impose civil penalties. The rule and the platforms' own policies decide how a request flow is built.

  • 16 CFR 465.2

    No fake reviews

    Writing, buying or selling reviews that misrepresent the reviewer or their experience is banned (Federal Register). Alfred replies to the reviews your customers write; he never writes reviews.

  • 16 CFR 465.4

    No paying for a particular opinion

    Offering compensation or incentives conditioned on a review being positive or negative is banned (Federal Register). Google goes further and bars incentives for any review (Google).

  • 16 CFR 465.5

    Insiders must say who they are

    An owner or manager who reviews their own business, or asks relatives or staff to write reviews, has to make sure the relationship is clearly disclosed (Federal Register).

  • 16 CFR 465.7

    No suppressing the bad ones

    Using threats or intimidation to stop or remove a review, or presenting the reviews you show as all or most of the reviews you got while hiding negative ones, is banned (Federal Register). Critical reviews get a reply, never a cover-up.

  • GOOGLE POLICY

    No review gating

    Google's Maps policy bars selectively soliciting positive reviews (Google). Every customer gets the same request, not only the ones who seemed happy.

  • YELP POLICY

    Yelp: don't ask

    Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews from anyone, and warns that prompted reviews may not be recommended (Yelp). On Yelp the work is accurate details and a reply to every review.

What a good reply looks like

Three invented reviews for an invented Houston HVAC company, with the kind of reply Alfred drafts.

Review (invented)ReplyWho approves
★★★★★, no text"Thanks for the five stars. We appreciate it."Posted automatically
★★★★★ "AC was out in July and they had it running the same afternoon.""Glad we got you cool again before evening. Thanks for trusting us, and we'll pass your note to the tech."Your choice per location
★★ "The quote doubled once he was in the attic.""Thanks for telling us, and we're sorry the price came as a surprise. Please call our service manager at the number on your invoice so we can go through it with you."Always a person

A good critical reply thanks the customer, names the problem without arguing and moves the conversation offline. It never offers anything in exchange for changing or removing the review, which would put you on the wrong side of both the FTC rule and Google's policy, and it never discloses details of the job or the customer.

One good month of reviews fades. A routine that runs every week compounds.

Google, Yelp, Facebook: where US customers read reviews

Google is where most local searches start, and Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help a business's local ranking (Google). Replies count too: Google's help says a reply shows customers you value their feedback (Google).

Yelp has the strictest line on asking: none at all (Yelp). What you control there is a claimed page with current details, and a calm reply to every review.

Facebook recommendations and trade sites such as Angi each set their own rules. A request flow has to point at the platform whose rules allow it, and the replies have to sound like the same business everywhere.

Your report

Your reviews, month by month

Every month: rating and replies for each location, next to the businesses customers compare you with, plus what is still waiting for a person to approve.

Win rate · Lindale Air & Heat 59% NOV
You Average of your competitors Example
4.9
Rating
GOOGLE PROFILE
100%
Reviews answered
ALFRED
41
New reviews this month
GOOGLE PROFILE
Example of a monthly report for Lindale Air & Heat: win rate 59 percent, with 4.9 rating, 100% reviews answered, 41 new reviews this month.

What the report holds

  • Rating and replies per location
  • Your rating next to nearby competitors
  • Critical reviews waiting for approval
  • Win rate against your competitors

What is the best way for a local business to manage reviews across Google, Yelp and Facebook?

Run one routine everywhere: ask every customer after every job, reply to every review in your own voice, and send critical ones to a person before anything posts. Follow each platform's rules: Google bars selective requests, and Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews at all. The FTC's review rule, in force since October 21, 2024, bans fake, bought and suppressed reviews (Federal Register).

  • Oct 21, 2024 the date the FTC's rule banning fake reviews and review suppression took effect FTC, Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465 (Federal Register)

Works with Reputation management

The map, the phone and every location

Questions

Straight answers.

How to manage online reputation?

As a weekly routine rather than a crisis job: a review request after every job, a reply to every review within days, critical ones routed to a person, and your details right on Google, Yelp and every listing. It slips the moment the routine stops, because competitors keep collecting reviews.

What are the best review sites?

The ones your customers read before they call: Google, Yelp, Facebook and the trade sites in your field, such as Angi for home services. Each has its own rules on asking: Google allows a request to every customer, and Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews at all (Yelp).

What's the best online reputation management software?

Judge any option on four points. Does it ask every customer the same way, as Google's policy requires? Do replies sound like you? Does a person approve every critical reply? And do your reviews and data stay yours if you leave? With Alfred they do, and he hands everything over.

How much does it cost to manage an online reputation?

Weigh it against what the work covers: a request after every job, a reply to every review and a person on every critical one, for every location, every week. With Alfred, pricing is per location and depends on what you need. Book a demo and you get a written price before you decide; how pricing works.

Should you reply to bad reviews?

Yes, calmly and quickly. The reply is written for the next customer as much as for the reviewer: thank them, name the problem without arguing and give a direct way to reach you. Never offer anything in return for changing the review, and never threaten the reviewer; both are covered by the FTC rule (Federal Register).

Free check

See your rating next to your competitors'.

Type your business name and get a free check in about a minute.

Book a demoNo credit card · No meeting needed