Win rate per location: see who's winning, and why
A brand-wide average hides the locations that are slipping. Win rate per location shows which win on their own, which are behind, the reason, and the next thing to do.
- 1 Brightline Dental Chandler ★ 4.9 · 286 reviews · 0.4 mi You
- 2 Ocotillo Family Dentistry ★ 4.8 · 471 reviews · 1.8 mi
- 3 Arizona Avenue Dental ★ 4.6 · 159 reviews · 1.1 mi
An average rank tells you how you did. A win rate per location tells you where to go next.
22.8% of ChatGPT's picks in Houston, Chicago and Phoenix were also in Google's 3-pack
From our study
The map and the AI answers rarely agree, which is why win rate counts both. When Alfred asked ChatGPT and Perplexity for the best local businesses in 15 searches in Houston, Chicago and Phoenix, 22.8% of ChatGPT's picks and 15.3% of Perplexity's were in Google's 3-pack for the same search (method). A location that is measured on the map alone can look strong and still go unnamed when a customer asks an assistant.
Source: Alfred, The AI Recommendation Gap 2026, US edition, 15 searches and 33 answers, October 20, 2026 (method)
The map part of the number.
On the map, every point across the trade area is a search of its own. Alfred records the location's rank at each point and whether it comes out ahead of the competitors you picked.
What goes into the number
Searches, competitors, surfaces, and one rule
Searches and competitors are chosen with you, per location, and every part of the calculation is shown.
-
Tracked searches
The terms customers use to find that location in its trade area: dentist near me, emergency dentist Chandler, teeth whitening Gilbert. Every location has its own list.
-
Chosen competitors
The businesses customers see next to that location on the map, in search results and in AI answers. Never your other locations, and never directory pages.
-
Three surfaces
Google Maps, read from many points across the trade area; Google Search; and AI answers from assistants such as ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity.
-
One rule
A search is won when the location is ahead of every chosen competitor in that result. Win rate is searches won over searches tracked; the full method is on How we count.
One location, one month
A made-up month for one invented dental office in Chandler, Arizona.
| Surface (made-up figures) | Tracked | Won | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Maps, grid points | 49 | 31 | 63% |
| Google Search | 10 | 4 | 40% |
| AI answers | 8 | 2 | 25% |
| This location | 67 | 37 | 55% |
In the example (made-up figures), 55% says the office is ahead more often than not, but the rows tell a sharper story. It wins the map on reviews and distance. It loses Google Search, where a competitor has a page for every treatment and neighborhood and the office has one page for everything. And the AI answers rarely name it.
So the next actions point at the website and the listings, not at the ads: service and area pages for the treatments patients search for, and the same name, hours and services on every listing. More ad spend would change none of those rows.
From number to next step
Every location gets a status and a next action
Next to its own competitors, every location falls into one of four bands. The band names the kind of problem; the next action names the fix for this week: fix a listing, answer reviews, add photos or move ad budget.
- Far behind Few reviews, a thin profile or one nobody owns. Start with the basics and a review request after every visit.
- Behind Strong organically, but competitors' ads sit above it. This is where ad budget earns its keep.
- Ahead or well ahead Ahead: answer reviews and keep asking. Well ahead: it wins without ads, so spend less there.
Ad budget
Spend where the gaps are
Locations that already win on the map don't need ads to be found. Locations that lose to paid competitors need them most. Alfred suggests each month's split by where every location is behind, next to an even split, and targets and budget are agreed with you up front.
- An even split and a split matched to win rate, side by side
- Each shift tied to the searches where competitors' ads sit above you
- Locations that win without ads flagged to spend less
Win rate across a franchise system
In a franchise system, corporate and the franchisees want different things from the same number. Corporate wants the whole portfolio on one screen, furthest behind first. A franchisee wants their own location against the three practices down the road, and the one thing to do on Monday.
Win rate serves both because it is counted the same way at every level. A location's figure is its searches won over its searches tracked. The group's figure is every location's wins over every location's searches, so a large location carries more weight, and the report prints each location's share next to the group's so a big one never hides a small one.
Head office sets the standard; local managers handle their own reviews and posts, with approvals where you want them. The monthly report comes per group and per location: win rate, map rankings and AI visibility, rating and replies, data accuracy, and the calls, website clicks and direction requests Google reports. If you report in a BI tool such as Qlik, an export or integration is scoped with you.
Every location, every week
What moves the number
Win rate is reported monthly. The work behind it is visible every week, location by location.
- 55%
- Win rate, this location
- ALFRED
- 67
- Tracked searches
- ALFRED
- 286
- Google reviews
- GOOGLE PROFILE
What the report holds
- Map position at every grid point for the searches you chose
- Whether the location is named when customers ask AI who to call
- The competitor ahead and what changed there: reviews, photos, ads
- The next action and who owns it at the location
- Which changes went live on maps and directories
Average rank or win rate?
Rank reports for multi-location brands usually show an average position per location. It is simple to produce and hard to act on.
| Average rank | Win rate per location | |
|---|---|---|
| Measures | Average position, usually on Google only | How often the location beats its own competitors, on three surfaces |
| Leaves out | Who is ahead of you, and how often | Nothing about the cause, because the cause is printed next to it |
| Compared with | No one in particular | The businesses customers see next to that location |
| Tells you about ad spend | Nothing | Where ads are needed and where they can be cut |
| Read as | One number that should go up | A list that starts with the location furthest behind |
Markets differ as well. Each location faces its own competitors, so the same average rank can mean a comfortable lead in one metro and a steady loss in the next. Win rate measures each location against the businesses around it, which is the contest the customer actually sees.
What is win rate and how do multi-location brands use it?
Win rate is the share of tracked searches where a location comes out ahead of the competitors customers see next to it, on Google Search, Maps and AI answers. Multi-location brands read it per location: the list starts with the location furthest behind, shows the cause next to the number, and ends in one next action per location. The brand's figure adds them all up.
Published November 9, 2026 · Last updated November 9, 2026
Part of Multi-location
The number says where. These do the work.
Questions
Straight answers.
How do I find out where I rank on Google?
For a local business, there is no single answer: the map result changes with where the searcher stands, and AI answers name different businesses from Google's. Search from several points in your trade area, and ask an assistant the same question twice. Win rate does this systematically, from many points, against the competitors you choose. Check my business gives a first read in about a minute.
How do I increase my ranking on Google?
Locally, Google ranks on relevance, distance and prominence, and says more reviews and positive ratings can help (Google). So: the right primary category and services, consistent details everywhere, a review request after every job and a reply to every review. Google also says there is no way to pay for a better local ranking.
Is SEO worth it for small businesses?
For a business that customers find nearby, the map pack and AI answers decide who gets the call, and that place can't be bought (Google). What makes it worth it is knowing which searches you win and lose. With several locations, win rate per location shows where the work pays off first.
Benchmark your locations
See which locations are behind.
Book a demo and Alfred benchmarks them all: win rate per location, the competitors ahead of each and where the budget does the most good first.
Book a demoFree · No credit card